25 All-Inclusive Resort Mistakes Most People Make
Mike and Laura Travel contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you make a purchase using one of our links, I may receive compensation at no extra cost to you.
Mike and I have done a handful of all-inclusive resorts at this point, and I’ll be honest with you.. the first one we ever booked, we probably made fourteen of the mistakes on this list.
We thought “all-inclusive” meant we just had to show up. So we didn’t research the resort tier, we didn’t pre-book anything, and we drank way too much rum punch on day one.
Then we wandered into a “free breakfast” that turned out to be a timeshare presentation we couldn’t escape for two hours.
This post is everything we’ve either done wrong ourselves or watched other travelers do at the resort while we politely sipped our piña coladas and thought “oh no, sweetie, no.”
After speaking with hundreds of other travelers, we’ve cumulated a list of things that they have done wrong at all-inclusives, too. So you aren’t just getting our perspective.
The good news is that all of these mistakes are completely avoidable once you know about them. None of this stuff is buried in fine print or industry secrets.
Here’s the full countdown, starting with the smaller stuff and working our way down to the biggest mistake of all. Save yourself the trouble.
MISTAKE #25: WEARING YOUR WRISTBAND ON YOUR DOMINANT HAND
I know, I know. This sounds like nothing.
But by day three, when you’ve gotten sunscreen on it, dunked it in the ocean, and brushed against your wet wrist a hundred times, you’ll wish you’d put it on the other arm.
Most resorts use that wristband for everything from food to drinks to room access, so you’re showing it constantly.
Putting it on your non-dominant hand keeps it cleaner and out of the way when you’re eating.
It’s a small thing, but you’ll thank yourself later.
Pro-Tip: Get compression packing cubes
I’m a light packer, but that doesn’t mean I don’t pack a LOT. No, no, I need all the comforts, but I don’t want to lug around three massive suitcases. We use vacuum compression packing cubes, and they are the absolute best travel investment we’ve made.
>> Click here to get the same compression packing cubes we use!
MISTAKE #24: FORGETTING A REUSABLE WATER BOTTLE
Almost every all-inclusive will give you tiny plastic water bottles around the pool and beach all day.
Which is fine until you’re on bottle number nine and feeling vaguely guilty about the trash situation.
A 32-ounce reusable bottle solves it instantly.
Mike and I bring insulated bottles now and refill them at the pool bar.
The drinks stay cold longer, you’re not constantly hunting down a tiny bottle, and you’re not contributing to a mountain of plastic that washes up on the same beach you’re sunbathing on.
Pro-Tip: Hydro-Flask
My go-to is a 32-ounce Hydro Flask. It keeps water cold for like 12 hours, even sitting on a 90-degree pool deck, and it’s survived multiple beach trips with no scratches. Worth every penny.
>> Click here to choose your water bottle color!
MISTAKE #23: BRINGING WAY TOO MUCH CASH
This one trips up first-timers constantly.
People show up with $500 in twenties expecting to need it, and then realize that almost everything is already paid for.
The wristband covers food, drinks, and most activities. The taxi to the airport was probably included in your transfer.
What you actually need is small bills for tipping.
About $100 to $200 in singles and fives is plenty for a week, depending on how much you tip and whether you’re doing any off-resort excursions.
Anything more than that just sits in the safe.
MISTAKE #22: SKIPPING THE KIDS’ CLUB OUT OF GUILT
This is for the parents.
The kids’ club at most all-inclusive resorts is included in your stay, run by trained staff, and full of activities your kid will love.
Yet so many parents feel weirdly guilty about using it.
Don’t.
Your kids will have an absolute blast doing crafts and swimming with new friends.
Meanwhile, you and your partner will get to sit by the pool and have an actual conversation. That’s part of what you paid for.
Drop them off without overthinking it.
Honestly, the parents who use the kids’ club come home from vacation more rested than the ones who don’t.
MISTAKE #21: PACKING REGULAR SUNSCREEN INSTEAD OF REEF-SAFE
If you’re going anywhere with coral reefs (so most of the Caribbean and Mexico), you’re going to want reef-safe sunscreen.
A lot of eco-parks like Xcaret and Xel-Ha in Mexico actually require it.
They’ll have you change out at the entrance if you bring the wrong kind.
Look for the words “reef-safe” or “biodegradable” on the bottle. Check that it doesn’t contain oxybenzone or octinoxate.
Mineral sunscreens with zinc oxide or titanium dioxide are your best bet.
Buying it at home is also way cheaper than buying it on the resort, where a bottle can run you $30 or more.
Pro-Tip: Thinksport
ThinkSport’s sunscreen is what we keep going back to. It’s reef-safe, and it’s non-toxic (according to the app, Yuka). We use it on our 2-year-old and we love it!
>> Click here to get ThinkSport sunscreen <<
MISTAKE #20: MISSING THE FREE NON-MOTORIZED WATER SPORTS
Most all-inclusive resorts include kayaks, paddleboards, snorkel gear, sometimes even sailboats and windsurfers, completely free.
Yet I’d guess about 60% of the guests at any given resort never touch any of it.
Walk down to the watersports hut on day one and ask what’s included.
The morning is usually the best time because the water is calmer and you’ll have your pick of equipment.
We’ve had some of our favorite vacation moments paddleboarding around the resort cove with nobody else out there.
Pro-Tip: Get a waterproof phone pouch
A waterproof phone pouch is hands-down the cheapest, smartest thing you can bring on a beach vacation. We’ve used ours in Moorea, Bora Bora, and Greece (after accidentally swimming with our phones TWICE). Saves your phone and lets you actually capture the water shots without panicking when a wave hits.
Not to mention, it’s like $7 for a pack of two.
>> Click here to get a protect your phone! <<
MISTAKE #19: FALLING FOR THE “FREE BREAKFAST” TIMESHARE PITCH
You will get approached.
Sometimes at check-in, sometimes by the pool, sometimes at the front desk.
Someone friendly will offer you a free breakfast, a free spa credit, a free excursion, or a free bottle of champagne.
All in exchange for “a quick 60-minute presentation.”
It will not be 60 minutes. It will be three hours, minimum.
Just say no.
The “free” gift is never worth the time you’ll lose, and the high-pressure sales tactics in those rooms are something else.
If you genuinely want a timeshare, fine, look into it on your own time after vacation.
But on a vacation you paid good money for, do not give up half a day to a sales pitch.
MISTAKE #18: DRINKING THE WELL ALCOHOL WHEN PREMIUM IS INCLUDED
This depends on your resort tier.
But at most mid-range and luxury all-inclusives, premium liquor is included in your package.
Yet bartenders default to the well stuff unless you ask. They’re not trying to scam you, it’s just easier and faster.
Ask. “Can I get this with Patrón instead of the house tequila?” or “Do you have a top-shelf rum?”
Nine times out of ten the answer is yes, and your drink is suddenly twice as good.
If you’re not sure what’s included, ask at the front desk on day one for the drink menu.
MISTAKE #17: NOT BOOKING SPECIALTY RESTAURANTS IN ADVANCE
Most all-inclusives have a few “specialty” restaurants beyond the buffet.
Think an Italian place, a steakhouse, a Japanese teppanyaki spot, or a beachside seafood restaurant.
They’re almost always included, but they require reservations, and the good time slots book up fast.
Book your specialty restaurants the moment you check in.
Some resorts even let you book before you arrive through the resort app or by emailing the concierge.
If you wait until day three, you’ll be stuck with 9 PM reservations or none at all.
Mike and I usually try to book one specialty dinner per night for the first half of the trip, then play it by ear for the rest.
MISTAKE #16: EATING EVERY MEAL AT THE BUFFET
The buffet is convenient, sure.
But by day four, you’re going to be tired of the same heat-lamp food.
The good stuff at all-inclusives is at the à la carte spots and the beach grills.
Mix it up.
Do the buffet for breakfast when the omelets are fresh, hit the beach grill for lunch, and save dinner for a specialty restaurant.
You’ll come home with way better food memories than “I ate at the same buffet for seven days.”
MISTAKE #15: SKIPPING THE SPA
A lot of all-inclusives include either a spa credit or at least free access to the hydrotherapy areas.
Think saunas, steam rooms, hot pools, cold plunges.
Even if the actual treatments cost extra, the wellness facilities are often part of your package and almost nobody uses them.
Take an afternoon and just go.
Even if you don’t book a massage, the steam rooms and plunge pools are an amazing reset on a vacation full of pool drinks and late dinners.
And if you do book a treatment, ask about the day rates because they’re often cheaper than what you’d pay at home.
MISTAKE #14: NOT PRE-BOOKING YOUR AIRPORT TRANSFER
Some resorts include transfers in your package, some don’t.
If yours doesn’t, do not just wing it at the airport.
The taxi situation in places like Cancun and Punta Cana is chaotic.
A one-off ride can run anywhere from $50 to $150 each way depending on where you’re going.
Pre-book a shared shuttle (around $20 to $40 per person round trip) or a private transfer through a service like Cancun Airport Transportation or Amstar.
It’s set up before you land, the driver meets you at arrivals, and you don’t get hassled by the wall of taxi guys outside the terminal.
We learned this one the hard way our first trip.
Quick Tip: Get luggage trackers
Speaking of the airport, drop an Apple AirTag in your checked bag before you go. Mine has saved me twice when bags went on a different flight than I did.
They pay for itself the first time your luggage decides to take a vacation without you.
>> Click here to get some Apple AirTags
MISTAKE #13: GOING OFF-RESORT FOR EVERY SINGLE MEAL
Some travelers get to the resort and then immediately start planning trips into town for “real food.”
That’s fine occasionally.
But if you’re doing it every day, you’re basically paying for an all-inclusive twice. Once at the resort and once at every restaurant you walk into.
Pick one or two off-resort meals during the week, ideally somewhere with real local character.
The on-resort dining is part of what you paid for, and at most decent resorts, it’s actually pretty good if you go to the right restaurants.
MISTAKE #12: NOT TIPPING AT ALL
I see this one all the time.
Travelers assume that because the resort is “all-inclusive,” tipping isn’t expected. Technically, that’s true. Practically, it’s not how it works.
The bartenders, servers, housekeepers, and concierge staff at most Caribbean and Mexican resorts are working long hours for low base wages.
About $1 to $2 per drink at the bar, $2 to $5 per day for housekeeping (left on the pillow each morning), and 10 to 15% on top of a specialty restaurant meal goes a long way.
You’ll also notice your service gets noticeably better when staff knows you’re a tipper.
Not in a sketchy way, just in a “they remember your drink order by day two” kind of way.
MISTAKE #11: BOOKING THE CHEAPEST ROOM WITHOUT READING WHAT’S INCLUDED
Resorts will price the basic room category to look like a steal.
Then the next tier up gets you swim-up access, a butler, premium liquor, à la carte breakfast, beach bed reservations, or a VIP lounge for an extra $40 to $80 a night.
Sometimes that upgrade is genuinely worth it. Sometimes it’s not.
The mistake is not even reading the comparison.
Look at what each tier actually includes before you book the cheapest one.
We’ve found that the second-cheapest tier is usually the sweet spot at most resorts.
You get the meaningful perks without paying for the over-the-top butler stuff most of us don’t actually use.
Quick Tip: Bring a travel pillow
If you’re flying more than 3 hours to your all-inclusive (Mexico, Punta Cana, Jamaica, etc.), don’t skip a comfy travel pillow. The little inflatable ones are pretty useless. And the neck pillows are mehh…
The memory foam ones on Amazon are your best shot at sleeping on the plane, which means day one isn’t a wash.
>> Click here to grab our favorite travel pillow!
MISTAKE #10: BOOKING FLIGHT AND RESORT SEPARATELY
I love a good Google Flights deal.
But for all-inclusives, bundling your flight and resort through Costco Travel, Funjet, Apple Vacations, or even Expedia’s package deals is usually noticeably cheaper than booking them separately.
The trick is that bundle pricing isn’t always obvious because the savings are baked in rather than shown as a discount.
Run the numbers both ways before you book.
Sometimes booking separately is still better, especially if you’re using points for the flight.
But most of the time the bundle wins. Mike and I book most of our resort trips this way for that exact reason.
NEED HELP BOOKING YOUR TRIP?
Booking a holiday is not nearly as fun as the holiday itself (or at least it isn’t for most people 😉). If you’d rather have a travel expert do it for you so you don’t miss any of the important details, fine print, or “important to knows”, let us book your trip for you!
We’ve been traveling full-time since 2014, so we have quite the eye for good travel plans.
>> Click here and we’ll help you book your trip for free!
MISTAKE #9: GOING TOO HARD ON DAY ONE
You arrive at the resort, you head straight to the swim-up bar, you order three rum punches before lunch.
By 4 PM you’re either asleep on a lounge chair or spectacularly sunburned. Maybe both.
I get it. The drinks are right there and they’re free.
But pacing matters at all-inclusives more than at any other type of vacation, because the alcohol flows for a full week.
Day one hangovers eat into days two and three. Bad sunburns last all week.
Drink water between drinks, ease into the sun for the first day, and save the marathon pool day for day three or four when you’re acclimated.
You’ll have way more fun overall.
MISTAKE #8: BOOKING AN EXCURSION EVERY SINGLE DAY
Excursions can be amazing, like swimming with whale sharks in Mexico or doing a catamaran sail in Antigua.
But they’re also exhausting and expensive.
Most run $80 to $200 per person, and they’re often not included in your all-inclusive package.
They also pull you away from the resort you already paid for.
Pick two excursions for the week, max. Three if it’s a longer trip.
Leave the rest of your days for the resort itself, because honestly, lazy days by the pool are why most people booked an all-inclusive in the first place.
If you’re running around on tour buses every day, you’re going to come home more tired than when you left.
MISTAKE #7: NOT CHECKING THE RESORT’S SIZE AND LAYOUT
This one bites a lot of people.
You see beautiful photos, you book the room, and you arrive to find out the resort is 1,000 acres with eight pools.
Three of the restaurants are a mile away, and the beach is a 20-minute shuttle ride from your room.
Pull up the resort map before you book.
Look at where the rooms sit relative to the beach, the main pool, and the restaurants.
Read recent reviews mentioning words like “huge” or “spread out” and decide if that’s actually what you want.
Bigger is not always better.
Some of our favorite all-inclusive stays have been at smaller resorts with under 200 rooms where you can walk anywhere in five minutes.
Quick Tip: Pack the right shoes
At a big resort, you’re walking 3 to 5 miles a day, easy. Decent sandals matter more than you’d think.
I live in my Olukai sandals on resort vacations. They look nice enough for dinner and they don’t shred your feet by day three.
>> Click here to order cozy vacation sandals
MISTAKE #6: PICKING A RESORT THAT DOESN’T MATCH YOUR TRAVEL STYLE
This is where reviews and research really matter.
A resort that’s perfect for spring breakers will be miserable for a couple looking to relax, and vice versa.
A family resort will drive a quiet couple insane. An adults-only luxury resort will make a family with kids feel out of place.
Be honest with yourself about what kind of trip you actually want.
Are you looking for nightclubs and pool parties, or hammocks and quiet sunsets?
Do you want a buzzing kids’ club or an adults-only beach? Is fancy food important, or are you fine with a solid buffet?
The right resort exists for every style.
The mistake is picking the wrong one because the photos looked nice, and not realizing the actual vibe doesn’t match what you want until you’re there.
MISTAKE #5: SKIPPING TRAVEL INSURANCE
I know, I know. Travel insurance feels like an upsell.
But for an all-inclusive trip where you’re often paying $2,000 to $8,000+ upfront, it’s genuinely worth the $80 to $150 it’ll cost you.
Here’s why. Flights get cancelled. People get sick. Hurricanes happen.
Mike and I had a friend who had to cancel a $5,000 trip three days before because of a family emergency.
Her insurance refunded almost all of it. Without it, that money would have been gone.
Look for a policy with “cancel for any reason” coverage and decent medical (medical evacuation from the Caribbean or Mexico can easily run $25,000 or more).
Hurricane protection matters too if you’re traveling during the season.
Companies like World Nomads, Allianz, and Travelex are all solid starting points.
MISTAKE #4: BOOKING DURING PEAK HURRICANE SEASON WITH NO BACKUP PLAN
The Caribbean and Mexico hurricane season runs June 1 through November 30, with the peak between mid-August and October.
September 10 is statistically the climatological peak of the entire season.
That’s a real fact, not me being dramatic.
Now, that doesn’t mean you can’t book during this window.
Resort prices are way cheaper, the crowds are thinner, and most weeks the weather is gorgeous.
But you absolutely have to book with a backup plan.
That means travel insurance with hurricane coverage, refundable or rebookable flights when possible, and resorts with a “hurricane guarantee” policy where they’ll let you rebook if a storm hits.
Going in blind during peak season is the kind of mistake that turns a dream trip into a $4,000 lesson.
MISTAKE #3: GOING BY INSTAGRAM PHOTOS INSTEAD OF REAL REVIEWS
Resorts spend a lot of money on photography.
The pool looks bigger, the beach looks emptier, the food looks plated like it’s a Michelin restaurant.
None of that is reality.
Read recent reviews on TripAdvisor, Reddit (r/travel and r/Caribbean are gold), and YouTube.
Look for reviews from the last three to six months because resorts go through phases where management changes or maintenance falls behind.
The patterns matter more than individual takes.
If you see ten reviews mentioning the same problem, like dirty rooms or rude staff or sargassum on the beach, believe them.
That’s not bad luck, that’s the resort.
The Instagram photo is a marketing tool. The 47 recent reviews complaining about the same broken air conditioner is the truth.
MISTAKE #2: PICKING A RESORT BASED PURELY ON PRICE
I have so much sympathy for this one.
Mike and I started our travels paying off debt, and we’d default to the cheapest option every time.
The thing is, with all-inclusives specifically, the cheapest option is almost never the best value.
The cheapest resorts are usually older properties, with smaller rooms, basic food, well alcohol only, and a vibe that’s more “tired” than “tropical.”
The mid-range resorts are often the best value because you get genuine luxury without the markup of the top-tier names.
We’ve stayed at $200-a-night-per-couple resorts that absolutely smoked $400-a-night-per-couple resorts.
The management was better, the food was fresher, and the staff actually cared.
Look at the second-cheapest tier on resort comparison sites. Read those reviews. Compare what’s actually included.
Sometimes paying $50 a night more saves you $300 on the trip in food and drink upgrades you would’ve bought anyway.
Cheapest isn’t the same as best deal. And at all-inclusives, the difference between the two is huge.
MISTAKE #1: ASSUMING ALL “ALL-INCLUSIVE” RESORTS INCLUDE THE SAME THINGS
This is the biggest one.
It’s the mistake that catches more first-time all-inclusive travelers than any other.
The phrase “all-inclusive” is not regulated. It means whatever the resort wants it to mean.
And the difference between a budget all-inclusive and a true luxury all-inclusive is enormous.
Some resorts include only buffet meals and well drinks. That’s it.
You’ll pay extra for à la carte restaurants, premium liquor, room service, the spa, the gym classes, and even the bottled water in your room.
Other resorts include literally everything.
Top-shelf alcohol, all restaurants, 24-hour room service, motorized water sports, even greens fees at the golf course.
The price tag does not always tell you which is which.
Before you book, get the actual inclusions list from the resort.
Most websites have a “What’s Included” page somewhere on the booking site, and it’s worth reading line by line.
The big things to check are whether the alcohol is top-shelf or just well, whether specialty restaurants are included or à la carte, and whether room service is free.
Then look at the smaller stuff like Wi-Fi, gym access, the spa, watersports, and the kids’ club.
Finally, check for any extra fees layered on top.
Some resorts pile on 10 to 18% in service charges, gratuity fees, or environmental taxes that don’t show up in the advertised rate.
This one mistake is responsible for most of the “I thought everything was free” stories you’ll hear from people who came home disappointed.
Once you understand that “all-inclusive” is a spectrum, not a guarantee, you’ll book the right resort every single time.
So there’s the list.
Twenty-five mistakes Mike and I have either made ourselves or watched/heard about from hundreds other travelers.
The good news is that almost all of these come down to doing about an hour of research before you book and going in with a small game plan once you’re there.
And if you take nothing else from this post, please do not give up your morning to a timeshare presentation. Trust me on that one.
